Lessons from the Underground Church and the Coming Decline of the Mega-Church

In today’s underground house church in China, we see a fellowship that has seemed strange to observers in the west, until today.

Due to the extreme persecution that Chinese Christians have experienced over the years, Christian fellowships did not meet together in large official government approved buildings complete with pews, lecterns, stained-glass windows, cathedral ceilings, Sunday school classrooms, libraries, bookstores, fellowship halls, decorative crosses, and digital signs complete with sermon titles and meeting schedules. Instead, Chinese Christian gatherings have taken place in small farm homes, urban apartments, factories, offices, fields, and caves.

I have personally brought hundreds of western pastors to China to attend secret meetings in different areas of China, from Xinjiang to Jilin, from Tibet to Inner Mongolia. I have watch them witness the revival flames in China in complete awe as they marvel at the lack of modernity, yet the sophistication of the personal networking. Time and time again, western Christians have admitted to me that there is something special in China’s underground house church that can be directly compared to the first-century church that we read about in the book of Acts.  The concept of church growth in China has not been dependent on the size or number of buildings.

I agree, and it seems that the church in the west might soon need to take notes from the underground church in China.

In the Gospels, Jesus does not set an outline for the concept of “church” as many of us in the west have come to understand it. What the Gospels make abundantly clear is that we, the followers of Christ, are the church – not a building. We are promised that “where two or three come together in my name, there am I with them.” (Matthew 18:20).

This concept is a promise to us that God will be with us no matter where we are! Whether we have a dedicated building for praising His name or not, He can be in our midst. We are not slaves to ceremony or cookie-cutter agendas. We are free from the shackles of geographical locations and denominational traditions.

Jesus made it super simple. He emphasized love, sacrifice, discipleship and fellowship, all of which can be experienced in both small groups or large gatherings. We can rejoice that His presence is not dependent on money or restricted by lack of resources. We are not bound by legislation or in need of favor from presidents or congressional bodies. Our faith is not restricted to the walls of a building that we have or do not have.

The underground church in China reminds us that the true message of freedom that Jesus gives is independent of our understanding, earthly legality, or man-made structures.

Witnessing first-hand the operation of the underground house church in China, I am compelled to ask – are our churches in the west less like the following that Jesus and the disciples built up and more like the network of Jewish synagogues? Have we implemented a system that is similar to the system that the Jewish people formed during their diaspora? Are there elements in the western church today that are similar to the church building, systems, and ceremony that we see with the synagogues in the New Testament?

I only ask, because if the west is to face persecution as the Chinese believers have been facing for more than 70 years, will there be an insurmountable emotional toll when there is a loss of tax-exemption status and full government take over of our brick-and-mortar buildings? Will there be a massive falling away from the faith when spiritual leaders no longer maintain social clout and recession-proof salaries, but instead inherit disgust, disdain, poverty and persecution? How many of us will reject the Gospel message when our buildings, investments, and traditional man-made monuments are threatened?

The underground church in China gives us hope that the testimonies found in the book of Acts were not only for Christians 2,000 years ago, but can be experienced by us today! The testimony of Chinese believers in 2022 can be the inspiration that we need, to cling to the freedom that comes through Christ and Christ alone.

If the glitz and glamour of the western mega-church crumbles in front of our eyes, we can rejoice that God has something better for us that can be found in the small groups that will inevitably sprout up in its place. The Chinese church has always been in line with church history and if the persecution promises of Jesus are true – will continue being the model for the future of the church until the Lord returns.

The completion of the Great Commission and the revival of the church is not dependent on our buildings, will not be stopped by persecution, and is not delayed by world-wide pandemics.

I have learned from watching the underground house church in China that the Great Commission will be completed by disciples who are willing to sacrifice everything, and perhaps that concept of sacrifice is best incubated in small groups.

Dr. Eugene Bach is a known trouble-maker with an active imagination and sinful past. He has a PhD, but is not a real doctor, so please do not call for him during a medical emergency on an airplane when someone is having a heart attack. Eugene started working for Back to Jerusalem in the year 2000 after a backroom deal involving Chinese spies, the NRA, Swiss bankers, and a small group of Apostolic Christians that only baptize in Jesus’ name. He spends most of his time in closed countries attempting to topple governments by proclaiming the name of Jesus and not taking showers. From time-to-time he pretends to be a writer. He is not good at it, but everyone around him tries to humor him.

8 Comments

  1. April Bell

    Thank you for standing as a watchman on the wall and sounding the trumpet. God bless to you and your family.

    Reply
  2. Mary Elllen Gilvey

    The Mega Church is good as long as they follow God/Allah and for Catholics and Christians Jesus Christ God. They must not follow Satan and all his empty promises and lies and deceptions and tricks and all his evil ways. God never does this. God only has good ways. The path to Heaven is to stay on course and follow God and all his ways and Truths. If you follow Satan then you only get sent to Hell for ALL Eternity. It’s easy and simple. Follow God.

    Reply
  3. Lee

    Their house church and book of Acts approach really resonates with something in my heart. Praying for the Lord to open this up here in NE Florida.
    One of your best blogs yet, Eugene.

    Reply
    1. Elisha

      Why don’t you start it?

      Reply
    2. Lee

      Hi Pat,
      Either of your states happen to be Florida,if you care to say? ☺

      Reply
  4. Pat Vheek

    Our church has many small groups and we have one house church and are about to start another house church in another state far fom our state. God is preparing us.

    Reply
  5. Lee

    Thanks for your encouragement, Elisha. I am definitely praying for His direction and clarity on finding and/or starting a house fellowship here.

    Reply
  6. Grace Kim

    How can we join the persecuted underground church being from the USA ?

    Reply

Leave your thought